| Rank | Team | Name | 1 (Pre-Merge) | 1 (Merge) | 1 (Post-Merge) | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6** | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | 17 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1st | Hapman Is Better | Jelly Bread | WIN | WIN | WIN | MID | MID | WIN | MID | UFE | MID | WIN | UFE | UFE | IN | WIN | WIN | WIN | WIN | NONE | WINNER |
| 2nd | The Blocks | Big Orange Fat Chicken Image | WIN | WIN | UFE | WIN | MID | WIN | UFE | WIN | WIN | WIN | UFE | MID | IN | UFE | UFE | WIN | WIN | NONE | RUNNER-UP |
| 3rd | The Watchers | Spiderweb & | WIN | WIN | MID | HIGH | UFE | MID | WIN | MID | WIN | UFE | D/A*** | IN | UFE | UFE | WIN | WIN | NONE | ||
| 4th | Yummy Wommy | BFDI Shirt | WIN | WIN | MID | MID | WIN | UFE | WIN | WIN | D/A | WIN | WIN | WIN | WIN | ||||||
| 5th | The Blocks | Car Door | WIN | WIN | UFE | WIN | MID | WIN | UFE | WIN | UFE | WIN | UFE | WIN | IN | WIN | WIN | WIN | OUT | ||
| 6th | Yummy Wommy | Plastic Bag | WIN | WIN | MID | MID | WIN | UFE | WIN | WIN | WIN | WIN | D/A | IN | WIN | UFE | WIN | OUT | |||
| 7th | Hapman Is Better | Sans | WIN | WIN | WIN | MID | MID | WIN | MID | UFE | WIN | WIN | D/A | IN | WIN | UFE | OUT | ||||
| 8th | Yummy Wommy | Golden Horseshoe | WIN | WIN | MID | MID | WIN | UFE | WIN | WIN | WIN | WIN | UFE | UFE | IN | UFE | UFE | OUT | |||
| 9th | The Blocks | Glass Case Holder | WIN | WIN | UFE | WIN | MID | WIN | UFE | WIN | WIN | UFE | UFE | UFE | IN | UFE | OUT | ||||
| 10th | The Watchers | Plastic Plate | WIN | WIN | MID | LOW | IMMUNE | MID | WIN | MID | WIN | WIN | WIN | WIN | IN | UFE | OUT | ||||
| 11th | Yummy Wommy | Patrick Popsicle | WIN | WIN | MID | WIN | WIN | UFE | WIN | WIN | UFE | WIN | UFE | UFE | OUT | ||||||
| 12th | Yummy Wommy* | Phone | OUT | Debuts in Episode 9 | DEB/UFE | OUT | |||||||||||||||
| 13th | The Watchers | Dice and Dicey | WIN | WIN | MID | UFE | UFE | MID | WIN | MID | UFE | UFE | OUT | ||||||||
| 14th | Hapman Is Better | Alien Necklace | WIN | WIN | WIN | MID | MID | WIN | UFE | MID | UFE | OUT | |||||||||
| 15th | Hapman Is Better | Kill | WIN | WIN | WIN | MID | MID | WIN | MID | UFE | QUIT | ||||||||||
| 16th | Hapman Is Better | Booky | WIN | WIN | WIN | MID | MID | WIN | MID | UFE | OUT | ||||||||||
| 17th | The Blocks | Creeper Logo | WIN | WIN | UFE | WIN | MID | WIN | UFE | OUT | |||||||||||
| 18th | Yummy Wommy | Brobee Birthday Cake.png | WIN | WIN | MID | WIN | WIN | UFE | OUT | ||||||||||||
| 19th | The Watchers | Mr. Game & Watch | WIN | WIN | MID | UFE | UFE | OUT | |||||||||||||
| 20th | The Watchers | Red Minion | WIN | WIN | MID | UFE | OUT | ||||||||||||||
| 21st | The Blocks | Sidewalk | WIN | WIN | UFE | OUT | |||||||||||||||
| 22nd | The Watchers* | Grey Guy | WIN | OUT | Debuts in "The Great Escape" | HOST | HOST | DSQ | |||||||||||||
| 22nd | Teamless | Electric Box | WIN | OUT | Debuts in "The Great Escape" | IN | IN | ||||||||||||||
| 22nd | Teamless | T-Shirt Cannon | WIN | OUT | Debuts in "The Great Escape" | IN | IN | ||||||||||||||
| 22nd | Teamless | Baxter | WIN | OUT | |||||||||||||||||
| 22nd | Teamless | Gold Wall | WIN | OUT | |||||||||||||||||
| 27th | The Blocks* | A wall with a face | OUT | ||||||||||||||||||
| 27th | The Blocks* | Incinerator | OUT | ||||||||||||||||||
| 27th | The Watchers* | Cracker | OUT | Debuts in "The Great Escape" | IN | IN | |||||||||||||||
| 27th | Teamless | Brick | OUT | Debuts in "The Great Escape" | IN | IN | |||||||||||||||
| 27th | Teamless | A Gun On A Table | OUT | ||||||||||||||||||
| 27th | Teamless | Blue Sponge | OUT | ||||||||||||||||||
| 27th | Teamless | Boat | OUT | ||||||||||||||||||
| 27th | Teamless | Bullet Bill Item | OUT | ||||||||||||||||||
| 27th | Teamless | Fake Apple | OUT | ||||||||||||||||||
| 27th | Teamless | Mutated Taco | OUT | ||||||||||||||||||
| 27th | Teamless | Pinky | OUT | ||||||||||||||||||
| 27th | Teamless | Sideways Cup | OUT | ||||||||||||||||||
Notes:
1 asterisk = This character wasn't competing on the show, but helped their team in the quiz in OTA 6.
2 asterisks = Hapman Is Better would actually be 1st and The Watchers would be UFE, But HDPWL and Kill were caught cheating, so Yummy Wommy placed 1st and Hapman Is Better were UFE.
3 asterisks = Spiderweb is currently dead, but Spiderdaddy can still play in the game, but not compete(Immunity because Spiderweb's dead).